I glanced on the Hide and saw that the thread about a perfect SHTF optic from the last spring is back, alive and well.
I commented on it early on, but then lost track of it. These threads are usually mental masturbation, but they are interesting in that they give you some insight into how people think about it.
It is interesting, but some of the most important things get skipped over.
Some think that they will be lone warriors roaming in the post-apocalyptic world of Mad Max.
Others think that they will be forming battalions of soldiers to protect their cul-de-sac.
On the gear side, the trend is to go into hyperspecialized recommendations and then defend those choices to the death.
The truth is usually much more fundamental.
In a societal collapse everything starts whittling down to the base societal unit: your family. If you are very close with someone, maybe your family and theirs. The whole "neighborhood banding together" thing is a short term effect before everything really goes to shit.
On the gear side, redundancy is the name of the game. Which exact optic you have is not super critical, but there are good reasons to have a primary and a backup optic on your gun.
The exact rifle does not hugely matter as long as it is something you have a lot of ammo for and that you can fix and repair when it goes down.
Ditto for the handgun.
That's one of the reasons I am so fond of ARs and Glocks. With some modicum of spare parts and simple tools, I can keep them running almost indefinitely.
With sighting system, lot's of things work. The most flexible setup we currently have is an LPVO with an offset or piggybacked RDS. More than one of my ARs also has offset XS sights ( https://alnk.to/eOMAfff ) just in case. They are pretty unobtrusive and it adds to my practice. Then there are also flashlights and lasers and those do help you aim a bit as well.
Whichever sighting system you choose, practice with it. I have seen plenty of excellent long range guys struggle with anything other than their supported bolt guns. In unforeseen situations, it pays to be a generalist.
Precision long range is what I like the most, yet I spend a lot of time practicing with everything else. Thankfully, I find almost everything firearm and optics related interesting, which is why there is rather broad coverage of different things on this website.
Which reminds me that I need to re-visit a couple of knife related topics.
Every time I see one of these SHTF discussions, I make a mental note that "these people are not sufficiently afraid of bladed weapons", then forget to follow up on it.
Discussions of electricity issues are common, but they usually die when someone mentions a generator and the fuel for it running out.
I live in the Southwest. I have an enormous battery from EcoFlow that can keep lights and a freezer running surprisingly well and for a while. I also have a portable solar panel to top the battery off during the day. In retrospect, one more solar battery to daisychain would not hurt and I need to do a little research on the latest developments. With batteries, I am waiting for a breakthrough with solid state cells or something like that. It will change the world when it happens.
Similarly, it might look weird, but if the whole Aptera thing works out, it will be very tempting. These look really strange, but there is something appealing about 40 miles of driving purely off of the solar battery.
https://aptera.us/
Another thing that does not get enough coverage in these discussions is mobility.
If you are worried about water, there are solutions for that too, like Source Hydropanel that keeps you properly hydrated off grid. I keep on thinking about investing into a hunting property somewhere and setting up some sort of an offgrid cabin there, so I look at these things.
By the time you add it all up, redundancy and modern off grid living are really not cheap, so it is a game for people with disposable income and willingness to spend it.
For the rest of us... train with what you have and do not be an asshole. That way, when SHTF, your neighbors will be less likely to take you out first.
I do train a lot, but that second part is a little rough...