HET, Part 7: The War of the 50mm glass. Setting the stage.
The title of this post is my attempt at theatrical exuberance. If that was not clear before, this should really clarify why I never had a snowball's chance of a career in performing arts. Some people are just born to be nerds, I suppose.
I have mentioned here and elsewhere that I am kicking of a new High End Tactical (HET) comparison. Interestingly, although very few people are actually willing to spend this much money on these, quite a few people want to know what the pecking order at the top is and whether one is significantly better than all the others.
I'll try to rank them in some sort of a reasonable way, but the choice between the options is usually not the same for everyone. Barring some potential surprises (and those are usually not good surprises), everything on the high end is very good. However, riflescope design is an art of compromises and different manufacturers make those compromises in different ways. As is most often the case in real life, the answer is more nuanced than a simple ranking from best to worst. The biggest driver for the comparison is the introduction of March 4.5-28x52 and Zeiss LRP 3-18x50. I am really curious to see how they stack up against the competition.
I originally decided to put this together because I was curious how the new March 4.5-28x52 stacks up against the competition. 52mm objective is sort of an "in between" size, but it is closer to 50mm than 56mm and since the scope is compact, it really fits better with 50mm designs.
I have spent quite a lot of time with a near production prototype of this scope and I know it is very nice. What I do not know is how it stacks up against the competition.
While we are talking about nuanced answers, if you were to ask me what the best precision oriented high end scope out there for everything across the board is, I can tell you right off-hand that this March is going to be in the top 3, simply on the strength of it having very wide FOV broadest magnification range of the group, reasonably compact size and light weight. I also have the background knowledge of what they changed compared to the prototype I looked at. However, if you were to ask me whether you should get this new march or the ZCO 4-20x50, I would really struggle with the answer. The easiest would be to find out whether you often use magnification above 20x, which reticle you prefer and how much value you put on locking turrets. Based on answers to those recommendations I can make a perfectly reasonable recommendation, but the dirty trick here, so to speak, is that since I know these two are really nice scopes and whichever one I recommend, you are not going to be disappointed. What I can't yet offer is a sufficiently nuanced answer on how they compare optically and optical comparison will be a really significant part of this effort.
I will obviously carefully look at the mechanical quality, both objective and subjective, but I really do not expect anything within this price range to give me any objective mechanical problems. That is definitely something to check though. Feel will be different, of course, and that is another potential differentiator.
Normally, when I do these, I make the announcement, then vanish into my "dark lord lair" for a few months only to emerge with the results.
I plan to do it differently this time. There will be supporter-only updates as I go along, so that I can get some feedback here and there and make sure I dig into the details that matter to you. Also, if any of you are within a reasonable driving distance of me, we can potentially arrange a meet somewhere for you to look at the scopes yourself.
Here are the contenders:
March 4.5-28x52 with FML-TR1 reticle (on its way here) https://bit.ly/32qOUhj
Zeiss LRP 3-18x50 (should be here in a couple of weeks) https://bit.ly/3nNYZNx
ZCO 4-20x50 with MPCT3x (already here)
Tangent Theta TT315M 3-15x50 (has been here for a few years) https://bit.ly/3p22gs0
S&B PMII UltraShort 5-20x50 with P4F and DTII+ turrets (has been here for a bit). https://bit.ly/3CKequw
Steiner M7Xi 2.9-20x50 with Tremor3 rerticle (got here last week. They only had it with Tremor3, so I had no choice) https://bit.ly/3r5sw7t
US Optics 3.2-17x50 with JVCR (I already reviewed this one, so it will only be here for the optics part of the comparison; I know the mechanics work) https://bit.ly/3l9u9gJ
I also have a mystery contender, of sorts, that I had not mentioned before. I do not think it belongs in this group in terms of features or price, but optical and mechanical quality are very good. One of the things I am looking to figure out while I am doing this is where it fits between these $3k+ scopes and $1500-ish designs that I consider to be the best bang for the buck, like Vortex Razor HD-LHT 4.5-22x50 and Element Nexus 5-20x50.