Optimal Magnification for Prismatics?
Traditionally, we are almost conditioned to believe that the optimal magnification for a prismatic riflescope is right around 4x.
The most famous examples are the high end ACOGs and Elcans adopted by various militaries around the world. While ACOGs come in a bunch of magnifications, the 4x32 TA31 (https://bit.ly/43dq92k) is easily the most prolific. Elcans have been either 3.5x or 4x for a while, until the switch power 1x/4x and 1.5x/6x models, with the former (https://bit.ly/3Mmn6OB) much more widely spread.
For quite a long time we did not have a ton of options in terms of magnification aside from a bunch of lesser known ACOGs.
Then, a slew of budget prismatics popped up from various Chinese OEMs. Most of these have not been awesome, but it became increasingly apparent that, in terms of durability, they were not bad and that there was a market for them.
The next generation of Chinese prismatics seems to have really hit it out of the park in terms of optical quality and mechanical ruggedness. Some have questionable reticles and other design decisions, but that is not the fault of the OEMs. Those are the things determined by the brands that market them.
Most notably, there are several OEMs in China that do really good work with this style of a riflescope, so this is an opportunity to get a very high quality image for comparatively reasonable money.
Primary Arms and SwampFox do some interesting things with 1x and 3x prismatics. PA, SwampFox, Vortex and Burris do very good, albeit different versions of 3x and 5x designs. In this case, PA, Vortex and Burris stick with small prism designs, while SwampFox does large prism ones (I've got a video on that coming soon with Swampfox Saber and Vortex Spitfire Gen2 5x side by side).
Element is jumping in with a large prism 5x30 and, out of the left field by really clever, 7x with a fully electronic reticle.
The thing with a prism size is that as the magnification goes up, you need a pretty beefy prism assembly to maintain the wide FOV characteristic of the prismatic image, so weight goes up.
However, as we all get increasingly used to piggybacked or offset red dot sights, it appears that there is more and more demand for higher magnification prismatic riflescope.
I have some ideas on the subject, but before I get into that, I am curious what you think:
What would be the optimal prismatic magnification for you? and why?