Small enclosed red dot sights are sort of all the rage right now with Aimpoint ACRO probably starting the trend. Although I can think of a few small enclosed red dots sight that preceded it, none had quite as loud of an impact as the Aimpoint. Once people figured out that it was possible to make an enclosed red dot sight that is not a whole lot bigger than regular compact reflex sight (think Trijicon RMR, Shield RMS, etc) we were off to the races. Much has been written about the advantages and disadvantages of the open vs closed emitter red dot sights by a bunch of people, me included. I am not going to rehash that in any significant detail. The most important things are as follows: enclosed emitter RDS are easier to ruggedize against drop ,easier to seal against the elements and easier to clean in the field. Open emitter red dot sights are still more compact and lower profile. My daily carry gun has an open emitter red dot sights for these exact reasons: I like the low profile, but there are truly innovatively clever enclosed reflex sights coming that might make me reconsider that.
Steiner MPS is a fairly high end and high quality enclosed red dot sight designed to compete against the Aimpoint ACRO and a variety of other reflex sights out there. My video review is attached and here are th eCliff's notes.
I liked the sight overall and it it has not given me any issues despite some rather spirited, albeit unintentional, durability testing. I like the somewhat aggressive muscular styling of the MPS. I think it is a nice design language for Steiner. Interestingly, all that surface morphology made the sight easy to grab. I ended up yanking on it quite a bit during malfunction clearance drills. Top mounted emitter offers a variety of advantages in terms of packaging and optical performance. Packaging-wise, MPS can co-witness with rather low height irons and generally did not require any changes in presentation drills. One of the drills I do involves cycling the slide one handed where I essentially hook the red dot housing on something: belt, pocket, heel of my shoe, etc. It worked well enough, but for using something close to the body (belt, for example), the shape of the housing could be done in a more conducive manner (there is a little ledge above the front lens and if it was a touch less sharp and a touch higher, I'd be happier), but it worked well overall. Another interesting side-effect of a top mounted emitter is that the parallax performance is very symmetrical left/right and slightly asymmetrical up/down. This lateral focus symmetry is an advantage of a top or bottom mounted emitters (one of the reasons why small pistol red dot sights with aspherical surfaces often have very good parallax performance). Since most things intended to be shot with a defensive weapon are vertically shaped, I'd rather have the parallax error on that axis. Overall, I liked the sight a good bit. In terms of features, I would not mind seeing a version with auto brightness adjust and with a more sophisticated reticle for use with compact magnifiers on carbines. Essentially, when using it on a carbine, I would not mind some additional reticle feature(s) to be used for holdover and for a 5 yard CQB aiming point.
Most of my testing was on a 10mm handgun, but it did spend some time on a pistol caliber carbine and on a lightweight AR. I would not hesitate to use it on either if your application does not require holdover.
https://bit.ly/37SCZvA