Kicking off the thermal discussion
In preparation, of the discussion on thermals I would like to have, I started putting together a spec table of sorts for the thermal devices I have been looking at in the last several months or so.
I plan to keep adding entries to it and even as I type this, I realize that the Trijicon REAP-IR I spent quite a lot of time with is not in there. I'll add it into the next iteration together with a couple of Pulsar and iRay products I really want to look at.
As a practical matter, I am really interested in commercial thermal devices that are not hugely expensive. None of them are truly cheap, but in practical terms, a $5k thermal has a much broader appeal than a $10k thermal.
From a performance standpoint, all of the ones in this table are built around VOX imagers and have somewhat similar noise and sensitivity performance, so I decided to not list NETD.
I am, for now, viewing these from the standpoint of hunting, i.e. from how far away can I see an animal the size of a hog well enough to place a shot into the right spot, so I calculated the Maximum Targeting Distance with that in mind. That is essentially a measure of angular resolution.
From the standpoint of finding something, however, you also need wide FOV and there is a tug of war with thermals between wide FOV and angular resolution. You will see what I mean if you examine the table in the attached image carefully.
I will go over the numbers and what they mean during the next live show.
Also, keep in mind that there are intangibles that are difficult to express as a simple numerical metric. For example, the quality of the image processing plays a huge role.
As far as where these are made, N-Vision and Trijicon are made in the US on BAE cores. The rest are, I believe, OEM'ed in China with various levels on involvement from the company that sells them.
Accufire, Burris and Steiner appear to be made by Guide Inrared in China. Steiner appears to have worked very closely with them on image processing. It is different from what I have seen from Guide in the past.
iRay is a house brand for the other larger OEM from China called Raytrontek. They do a really good job on image postprocessing, but I do not know if that comes from internal resources or from a partnership with someone else.
Leica thermals appear to be made by Raytrontek as well, but the industrial design is very Leica and the image enhancement looks to be a partnership between Leica and Raytrontek. I would not be surprised if some of that expertise spills over into iRay products. The "utraclear" image enhancement in iRay and Leica have obvious similarities.
Leica menu system is distinctly different from anything else here, so Leica clearly had a lot to do with the software.
Note that on the top left of the snapshot are the FOVs of the three LPVOs I recently used with thermal clip-ons. To figure out what base dayscope magnification a particular clip-on is designed for, see what magnification matches the horizontal FOV of a particular clip-on.
Let me know what questions come up at this stage and we will tackle them one at a time.